
Where did I find such a treat?
This recipe comes from Recipe Girl, who adapted the recipe from Martha Stewart. I knew I had to try to make these as soon as I stumbled across the recipe. I love, love, love a snickerdoodle, so I just assumed a snickerdoodle in cupcake form WITH FROSTING would be amazing, and I was right.
I got 99 problems, and Baking is one:
So apparently the temperature in my apartment is determined to screw with my baking at all times. Last week it was too hot for my egg whites to form into peaks, and this time, it was freezing cold and my butter at room temperature was still too cold for creaming. I had left it out forever, tossed into the bowl with my sugar, attempted to start creaming and then tragedy struck. I was stuck, all clumped together, not making any kind of progress in the creaming department. It was a disaster. I ended up having to toss the whole damned thing into the microwave to get it soft enough to cream together. After creaming the butter and sugar I had to add the eggs 1 at a time. Thanks to my friend Marianne I knew that by leaving eggs in some tepid water for a bit, I could have room temperature eggs in no time, so no troubles on that front.
Everything is mixed and looking yummy and now onto pouring the batter, Hooray! Except how the hell do i pour this batter that won’t actually pour? Well, I started spooning the mix into the paper lined cupcake tin and realized that I suck at this too. Instead of putting the batter into the cups, I kept getting enough batter on the cup for it to get stuck onto my spoon, so there were partially filled cupcake liners flying everywhere. Eventually, I got into a groove and filled all 24 cupcakes.
24? Wait that’s weird, why did the recipe say it would yield 28 cupcakes? How exactly did I end up with 24 perfectly filled liners? I overfilled the damned cupcakes. Actually that isn’t true, I over filled a bunch of the cupcakes, not all of them. (See perfectly sized cupcake in the picture)
They baked up in about 18 minutes. They smelled amazing, and I was sure they would taste good, but the very first thing I noticed when I took them out of the oven was that every single one of them was totally flat. They didn’t have that cute domed look of so many cupcakes, including the picture of the recipe I was following. I did a bit of googleing and it turns out the flat top can be a result of old baking powder, or not creaming properly. I know the latter is true and honestly, I would almost bet my baking power is old too. So, two out of two ain’t bad right? Erm…wait, it is bad.
The frosting was killer easy, and very tasty. Honestly cream cheese frosting, what is there not to love? The little cinnamon sugar sprinkle as a finishing touch turned into having a lot of leftover cinnamon sugar, because what was supposed to be a 1/2 tsp of cinnamon really became 1 tablespoon of cinnamon. DOH!
Lessons learned:
- The temperature in my apartment sucks.
- Butter at room temperature should give a bit when squeezed, not just seem slightly warmer than when it comes out of the fridge.
- Room temperature eggs can be left out, or if you can plan in advance they can be left into tepid water to warm up a bit.
- I need to be a bit more patient while pouring/spooning batter into the liners.
- DO NOT OVERFILL THE CUPCAKES.
- 1/2 tsp does NOT equal 1tblsp